Menu

 

*Please note, only our Gluten Free pizzas are available in the 12″ size. Not all ingredients are gluten free so please be sure to confirm with our staff before placing your order.

The City: Our Classic Pizzas

  • The New Yorker

    The New Yorker

    Our classic cheese pizza
    Gluten Free (12") = $15.99 |14” = $10.75 |18” = $14.99 |24” = $21.99 |Giant Slice = $3.03

  • The Godfather Deluxe (LOADED W/ RONI)

    The Godfather Deluxe (LOADED W/ RONI)

    Loaded with Pepperoni (3X)
    14” = $13 |18” = $19.79 |24” = $30.24 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") = $18.24 |

  • The Bronx Deluxe

    The Bronx Deluxe

    Pepperoni, Italian sausage, Minced garlic
    |14” = $13 |18” = $19.78 |24” = $30.24 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") = $18.24

  • The Brooklyn Deluxe

    The Brooklyn Deluxe

    Pepperoni, minced garlic. fresh chopped basil
    14” = $13 |18” = $19.79 |24” = $30.24 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") $18.24 |

  • The Harlem

    The Harlem

    Meatballs, jalapeños, cream cheese dollups or drizzle
    |14” = $13.25 |18” = $20.18 |24” = $30.74 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") = $19.74 |

  • The Yankee

    The Yankee

    Breaded chicken, black olives, mushrooms.
    14” = $13.25 |18” = $20.18 |24” = $30.74 |Giant Slice = $4.99 | Gluten Free (12") = $18.49

  • The Beach Bum

    The Beach Bum

    Canadian bacon, pineapple, roasted red peppers.
    14” = $13.25 |18” = $20.18 |24” = $30.74 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") = $18.49 |

  • The Mobster

    The Mobster

    (Meat Lovers) Pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, bacon.
    14” = $13.75 |18” = $21.39 |24” = $32.99 |Giant Slice = $4.99| Gluten Free (12") = $18.99 |

  • The Grand Central

    The Grand Central

    Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, black olives, Onions.
    14” = $14.50 |18” = $22.99 |24” = $35.74 |Giant Slice = $6.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.74 |

Madison Square Garden: Our Vegetarian section

  • The Central Park

    The Central Park

    (Veggie Supreme): Spinach, black olives, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms.
    14” = $14.50 |18” = $22.99 |24” = $35.74 |Giant Slice = $6.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.74 |

  • The Park Ave

    The Park Ave

    Fresh tomatoes, red onion, artichoke hearts, finished with pesto over the top.
    14” = $14 |18” = $21.78 |24” = $33.49 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.24 |

  • The Soho

    The Soho

    Garlic oil base, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, feta.
    14” = $13.50 |18” = $20.57 |24” = $31.24 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $18.74 |

  • The Manhattan

    The Manhattan

    Red onions, fresh tomatoes, spinach, minced garlic
    14” = $13.75 |18” = $21.39 |24” = $32.99 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $18.99 |

  • The Queens

    The Queens

    Artichoke hearts, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes.
    14” = $13.25 |18” = $20.18 |24” = $30.74 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $18.49 |

  • The Athens

    The Athens

    Black olives, red onions, spinach, feta.
    14” = $14 |18” = $21.78 |24” = $33.49 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.24 ||

  • The Staten Island

    The Staten Island

    Fire roasted tomato base, fresh basil leaves, red onions.
    14” = $13.25 |18” = $20.18 |24” = $30.74 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $18.49 |

  • The Times Square

    The Times Square

    Zesty garlic broccoli, fire roasted tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions.
    14” = $14.25 |18” = $22.17 |24” = $33.99 |Giant Slice = $5.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.49 |

5th Avenue: Our deluxe section

  • The Grand Central

    The Grand Central

    (Supreme): Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, black olives, red onions.
    14” = $14.50 |18” = $22.99 |24” = $35.74 |Giant Slice 6.25| Gluten Free (12") = $19.74 |

  • The Spicy Mushroom

    The Spicy Mushroom

    Spicy marinara, mushrooms, pepperoni, red onions, minced garlic.
    14” = $15.25 |18” = $24.59 |24” = $38.49 |Giant Slice = $6.25| Gluten Free (12") = $20.49 |

  • The Long Islander

    The Long Islander

    Garlic Alfredo base, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, breaded chicken.
    14” 19.74 |18” = $22.56 |24” = $34.74 |Giant Slice = $6.25 | Gluten Free (12") = $19.74

  • The Ultimate B.L.T.

    The Ultimate B.L.T.

    Bacon, grilled chicken, lettuce, fresh tomatoes, ranch dressing drizzled over the top.
    14” = $15 |18” = $23.77 |24” = $36.74 |Giant Slice = $6.25 | Gluten Free (12") = $20.24 |

  • The Gyro Pizza

    The Gyro Pizza

    Gyro meat, red onions, fresh tomatoes, lettuce, with fresh tatziki sauce drizzled over the top.
    |14” = $15 |18” = $23.77 |24” = $36.74 |Giant Slice = $6.25| Gluten Free (12") = $20.24

  • The Bruschetta Pizza

    The Bruschetta Pizza

    Homemade pesto base, artichoke hearts and tomatoes in a balsamic blend, parmesan cheese.
    14” = $15 |18” = $23.77 |24” = $36.24 |Giant Slice = $6.25|Gluten Free (12") = $20.24 |

  • Creamy Bruschetta Pizza

    Creamy Bruschetta Pizza

    Cream cheese base, artichoke hearts & tomatoes in a balsamic blend, pesto over the top
    Gluten Free (12") = $20.49 |14” = $15.25 |18” = $24.16 |24” = $37.49 |Giant Slice = $6.25

  • The All American

    The All American

    Mozzarella and cheddar cheese, barbeque chicken, red onions, jalapeños , tater tots, and drizzled with our house honey beer barbeque sauce.
    14” = $16.00 |18” = $25.67 |24” = $39.99 |Giant Slice = $6.26| Gluten Free (12") = $21.24

  • The Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    The Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    A blended buffalo sauce base, grilled chicken, red onions, and tomatoes. ranch or bleu cheese on the side or drizzled over the top.
    14” = $14.25 |18” = $22.17 |24” = $33.99 |Giant Slice = $6.25|Gluten Free (12") = $19.49 |

  • The Sicilian

    The Sicilian

    (Deep dish pizza): Our traditional pizza served on a thick 16” square crust.
    16" = $17.99 | Additional topping = $1.60 | **$1.99

  • The Meat Breakfast Pizza

    The Meat Breakfast Pizza

    Scrambled eggs as the base, Italian sausage, bacon, onion, green peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, tater tots & cinnamon sugar crust.
    14” = $13.99

  • The Veggie Breakfast Pizza

    The Veggie Breakfast Pizza

    Scrambled eggs as the base, tomatoes, mushrooms, onion, green peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, tater tots & a cinnamon sugar crust.
    14" = $13.74

Ingredients

Build your own!

Gluten Free = $0.75 | 14″ = $0.75 | 18″ = $1.60 | 24″ = $2.25 | Giant Slice = $0.50

Deluxe top notch toppings**

Gluten Free $1.00 | 14″ = $1.00 | 18″ = $1.99 | 24″ = $3.25

SAUCES

Classic Marinara
Spicy Marinara**
Pesto**
Southwest Chipotle Pesto**
Olive Oil and Garlic
Garlic Alfredo**
Cream Cheese**
Spicy Cream Cheese**
Cream Cheese and Pesto**

Honey Beer BBQ**

Spicy Bleu Cheese**

Eggs**

Fire Roasted Tomatoes**

Any Wing Sauce**

 

MEATS

Bacon
Grilled Chicken**
Breaded Chicken**
Spicy Chicken**
Barbeque Chicken**
Canadian Bacon
Meatballs
Pepperoni
Italian Sausage
Gyro meat**
Anchovies**

VEGGIES

Artichoke Hearts
Black Olives
Green Olives
Green Peppers
Fresh Jalapeños

Pickled Jalapeños
Mushrooms
Red Onion
Roasted Red Peppers**
Green Chilie**
Broccoli**
Zesty Garlic Broccoli**
Spinach
Banana Peppers**

VARIOUS

Pesto**
Pineapple
Tomatoes
Fire Roasted Tomatoes**
Tater Tots**
Sun Dried tomatoes**
Fresh Basil

Cream cheese topping**

Tatziki (cucumber sauce)**

Ranch topping**

BBQ sauce topping/base**

Spicy Ranch topping**

Spicy Bleu Cheese topping/base**

Sweet n’ Sour Chili Sauce topping/base

Franks Red Hot topping/base

Southwest Chipotle Pesto topping**

Any of our wing sauces topping

 

CHEESE

Extra Mozzarella
Ricotta
Feta
Cream Cheese

Cheddar cheese

Side items

  • Garlic Knots

    Garlic Knots

    Casbah's version of garlic bread. Our dough tied into a knot, baked, seasoned with our garlic sauce and topped with melted mozzarella with marinara sauce for dipping
    6 $3.50 - 12 $6.75

  • Supreme Garlic Knots

    Supreme Garlic Knots

    Choose any 3 toppings to be cooked over your garlic knots
    6 $5 - 12 $9.50

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Mozzarella Sticks

    Breaded mozzarella deep fried and served with marinara for dipping
    6 $4.50 - 12 $8.75

  • Wings: Traditional Hot

    Wings: Traditional Hot

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Ragin’ X-Hot

    Wings: Ragin’ X-Hot

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Death Hot

    Wings: Death Hot

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Honey Beer Barbeque

    Wings: Honey Beer Barbeque

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Spicy Garlic

    Wings: Spicy Garlic

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Spicy Garlic Teriyaki

    Wings: Spicy Garlic Teriyaki

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Teriyaki

    Wings: Teriyaki

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Southwest Chipotle

    Wings: Southwest Chipotle

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Zesty Garlic Parmesan

    Wings: Zesty Garlic Parmesan

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Spicy Barbeque

    Wings: Spicy Barbeque

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Honey Mustard

    Wings: Honey Mustard

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Spicy Honey Mustard

    Wings: Spicy Honey Mustard

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

  • Wings: Sweet N’ Sour Chili Sauce

    Wings: Sweet N’ Sour Chili Sauce

    Comes with a side of ranch or bleu cheeses
    6 wings $5 - 12 wings $9.50

Salads

  • House Salad

    House Salad

    Fresh tomatoes, red onions, mozzarella cheese on top of crisp romaine lettuce
    Side $3.25 – Full $5.50 – Party Size $19.99

  • Greek Salad

    Greek Salad

    Crisp romaine, black olives, red onions, feta, tomatoes, tatziki dressing. Add Gyro meat for an additional $.50
    Side $3.25 – Full $5.50 – Party Size $19.99

  • Caesar Salad

    Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine lettuce sprinkled with parmesan cheese
    Side $3.25 – Full $5.50 – Party Size $19.99

Sandwiches

  • Meatball Parmesan Sub

    Meatball Parmesan Sub

    Homemade meatballs baked in our classic marinara with mozzarella and parmesan cheese served on a toasted bun.
    6" = $6.50 | 12" = $12.75

  • Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Breaded chicken baked in our classic marinara with mozzarella and parmesan cheese served on a toasted bun.
    6" = $6.50 | 12" = $12.75

  • The Texas NY

    The Texas NY

    Grilled chicken layered in our house honey beer BBQ sauce, onions, Jalapeños , and tater tots. Ranch or bleu cheese on the side.
    6" = $6.50 | 12" = $12.50

  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

    Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese on a toasted bun.
    6" = $6.50 | 12" = $12.75

  • The Supreme B.L.T. Sub

    The Supreme B.L.T. Sub

    Your choice of grilled or breaded chicken, bacon, fresh tomatoes, and lettuce served on a toasted bun. Comes with ranch or bleu cheese.
    6" = $6.50 | 12" = $12.50

  • Gyro

    Gyro

    Pita bread stuffed with lamb, tomatoes, onions, lettuce, and tzatziki sauce...$3.99 Add Feta, Mushroom, or Jalapeños for $.35 ea.
    $4.99

  • Chicken Caesar Pita Sandwich

    Chicken Caesar Pita Sandwich

    Toasted pita bread sprinkled with parmesan cheese stuffed with a fresh Caesar salad and your choice of grilled or breaded chicken..$3.99
    $4.99

Sweet Things

  • Zeppolis

    Zeppolis

    Bits of fried dough coated in cinnamon or powdered sugar, and layered with creamy frosting
    Small $3.50 – Large $6.50

  • 3 mini Cannolis

    3 mini Cannolis

    Stuffed with rich cannoli cream
    $3.50 - Chocolate shells $4

  • 3 mini Chocolate Cannolis

    3 mini Chocolate Cannolis

    Stuffed with rich cannoli cream
    $3.50 - Chocolate shells $4

Drinks

  • Sodas

    Sodas

    Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Barqs Root Beer, Mellow Yellow, Lemonade, Raspberry Ice Tea
    22oz = $1.45 | 32oz = $1.99

  • Liter Sodas

    Liter Sodas

    Coke, Diet Coke & Sprite
    $3.25

  • Draft Beers

    Draft Beers

    Rotating drafts from New Belgium Brewing & Odell Brewing Co.

Back to the Top